New Witchy Romcoms & Romances To Add A Bit Of Magic To Your Reading Life

Love’s A Witch by Tricia O’Malley

Read it if you want: Charmed meets magical small town goodness in Scotland

A witch is summoned by her grandmother to break their centuries-old family curse in the magical Scottish town she thought she’d never see again.

Already reluctant about returning to Briarhaven, she finds herself clashing with the grumpy mayor who is determined to protect the town from her chaotic magic.

Out now.

Witch You Would by Lia Amador

Read it if you want: reality tv competition goodness + celebrity romance but make it witchy

A young witch gets the life-changing opportunity to compete on a spellcasting reality tv show. The twist of the season is that they get a celeb teammate and Penelope finds herself stuck with a man she can’t stand who is known for goofy viral spell videos.

Unbeknownst to Penelope, her partner has a secret — he is also the pen pal she’s been corresponding with who has gotten to know the real him.

Out now.

An Ancient Witch’s Guide To Modern Dating by Cecilia Edward

Read it if you want: dating hijinx featuring an older MC who has time traveled far into the future

A 39 year old witch living in the 17th century finds her attempts to find love become even complicated when a potion goes awry and sends her 350 year years in the future to a whole new world and the ups and downs of modern dating.

Out now.

Head Witch In Charge by Avery Flynn

Read it if you want: a spicy enemies-to-lovers witchy romance with a disaster road trip

A witch ends up on a road trip to find an ancient spell book in exchange for a divorce to the man she married on a whim in Vegas and who happens to be the heir of her family’s enemies.

Out now.

A Spell For Midwinter’s Heart by Morgan Lockhart

Read it if you want: a Christmas-time witchy read with Hallmark vibes

A witch, who has sworn off magic, has returned home for her small town’s winter festival only to realize she must help save the festival along with her estranged coven and her handsome high school rival who is partly responsible for the predicament they are in.

Out September 25.

Violet Thistlewaite is Not a Villain Anymore by Emily Krempholtz

Read it if you want: more cozy fantasy romance than witchy rom-com

A powerful plant witch, looking for a fresh start after a life of working with a dark sorcerer, must work together with a grumpy alchemist to save her new town from a magical plague.

Out now.

Everything She Does Is Magic by Bridget Morrissey

Read it if you want: a book that feels like injecting Fall into your veins with a Stars Hollow vibe setting

This one is a YA romance set in a Stars Hollow coded town where it is Halloween every day and features a broody witch-in-training and a bubbly mortal who need to team up together for their Fall festival and other hidden agendas.

Out now.

P.S. Check out my list of recs for new and favorite YA books featuring witches.

Season of the Witch by Sophie H. Morgan

Read it if you want: a witchy romcom with more of a wintry vibe than a Fall one

This is the third book in the Toil and Trouble season though I believe it technically could be read as a standalone though you’ll miss out on the world and the dynamics.

Two exes, after the merging of their family businesses, must work together and fake being a couple on a holiday getaway to secure an important investment. Plenty of past feelings could complicate the ploy but the real kicker is a spell gone a lilttle awry that has erased Henry’s memories of Tia.

Out now.

Love Spells Trouble by Nia Davenport

Read it if you want: A fake dating rom-com between two teen witches

Two teen witches, from very different social classes, engage in a fake dating scheme in order to save a family bakery. Cute rom-com that also touches on various social and class issues.

Out now.

Hot Hex Boyfriend by Carly Bloom

Read it if you want: a light-hearted witchy rom-com, quirky family shenanigans, cozy small town feels

Delia’s family has always claimed that the woman in the family are witches but a hex took away all their powers. She might have believed it as a child but as and adult she think it — and their belief that she’s an especially powerful witch — is just a tall tale.

When Delia breaks the curse without even realizing it, this isn’t just a surprise to her but to the hot temporary neighbor who has been keeping an eye on the family to make sure the hex HIS family put on hers isn’t broken.

Rewitched by Lucy Jane Wood

Read it if you want: cozy fantasy romance, slow burn romance, found family, magical trials, 30-somethng characters, really good self discovery, all the best vibes of 90’s witchy stuff meets new & fresh, Stars Hollow vibes but make it British

A burnt out witch and bookshop employee risks losing her magic forever if she can’t pass the trial her coven has tasked her with and convince them of her worthiness as witch — a task made harder by a saboteur of some sort thwarting her success.

She must rely on the help of an assortment of people in her life on this journey to prove her worthiness to the coven and herself — including the charming & frustrating watchman who has been tasked with keeping her out of danger.

Hex & Hexability by Kate Johnson

Read it if you want: something with Bridgerton vibes but make it witchy

This one feels like it’s for all the Eloise Bridgerton girlies.

It’s about a young woman who is not all about that Society life — she cares little about getting married and wants a life outside of the Ton. With the arrival of a mysterious aunt, certain aspects of her life start to make sense when she finds out that she’s actually a witch. This knowledge introduces her to a magical side of London she never knew and a duke who is just as much as an outsider as her.

P.S. The other two witchy romance reads from this author are on Kindle Unlimited.

A Spell For Heartsickness by Alistair Reeves

Read it if you want: a MM witchy romance with some spice (and on Kindle Unlimited!)

An aspiring fashion designer knows he is destined to a cursed early death like his mother but is determined to make a name for himself before the inevitable happens. That dream seems to take a detour when the placement he was hoping to get in the city, thanks to a prophecy, sends him to an unwelcoming small town in search of his destiny instead — a destiny with no easy answers with two enchanting men as contenders and magical forest that could be related to his curse.

Truly Madly Magically by Hazel Beck

Read it if you want: a Stars Hollow-esque small town and a second chance romance

Another one that I’m going to say technically COULD be read as a standalone but I think there’s too much overlap from book to book to make it the best reading experience. The first two books in the Witchlore series are on Kindle Unlimited and a fourth will be out NEXT Fall so get caught up!!

This one, not shockingly with how the last book set up, focuses on Ellowyn and Zander and their tumultuous relationship as they need to work together to face attacks targeting Ellowyn from the Joywood coven and their own coven preparing for Ascension.

De-Witched by Sophie H. Morgan

Read it if you want: a grumpy/sunshine romance between a warlock on a mission and a human who isn’t supposed to know him/witches exist

This one is about a human woman named Leah who knows, even though she shouldn’t, all about witches and magic as she is friends with some witches and co-owns a bar with them.

When the warlock she met at a high society witchy masquerade ball – a ball she definitely wasn’t supposed to be at – walks into her bar she knows exactly who he is and he has NO idea that she was the woman behind the mask there.

He’s a powerful warlock who has been sent to live among humans for three months – without his powers – as part of a condition in his parents will and before inheriting his family’s business.

He has no idea his new boss is the woman he met weeks ago nor that she knows about witches/magic. And she’s in for a surprise when he isn’t quite the Prince Charming she thought him to be from that night.

Not Your Crush’s Cauldron by April Asher

Read it if you want: a spicy friends-to-lovers and forbidden romance between a straight-laced witch and her bad boy guardian angel

This is the third book in the Supernatural Singles series.

A straight-laced witch and professor of the supernatural challenges her students to get outside of their comfort and realizes she needs to do the same so she makes herself a list of some daring and challenging things for her.

Unbeknownst to her, this list ends up making her higher risk and getting assigned her very own guardian angel who happens to be her new roommate and long-time secret crush.

He can’t tell her she’s his new assignment and he also can’t have feelings for her as her guardian angel making the secret crush he’s had on her harder to keep at bay while they are living together and spending time on her list.

Potions & Proposals by Kate Callaghan

Read it if you want: a cozier witchy romance, rivals-to-lovers romance

This one is about two childhood rivals whose coven gives them an ultimatum — after pranking gone wrong and both being nominated to the successor to the retiring High Priestess — to either be magically bound together to prove they can work together or risk their possible banishment.

A spell gone wrong, in an attempt to prevent the binding, makes things even more complicated and they will need to find a solution together.

ON KINDLE UNLIMITED AT TIME OF POSTING.